‘The alternative was to do nothing’ | Blount County DA calls for change after former gym teacher‘s sentencing
Joseph Dalton is a former Blount County gym teacher who was recently sentenced for several charges of assault against elementary school students.
MARYVILLE, Tenn. (WVLT) - The Blount County District Attorney behind the sentencing of a former gym teacher accused of inappropriately touching students released a statement explaining the laws as they currently stand and his reasoning behind the charges.
Joseph Dalton is a former gym teacher who was recently sentenced for several charges of assault against elementary school students.
Dalton worked for several elementary schools in Blount County and faced multiple complaints from parents and students who said he assaulted them physically.
Previous Coverage: Former Blount County gym teacher sentenced in student assault cases
The former teacher was sentenced Wednesday to six months of supervised probation after pleading guilty to assault in September.
There has been an outcry in the Blount County community, and Fifth Judicial District Attorney General Ryan Desmond, who was over Dalton’s prosecution, released a statement explaining how the case developed, the laws currently in place and his reasoning behind the charges.
Desmond said he became aware of an incident involving a young student in early 2023, and after an extensive review of surveillance video from every class Dalton had participated in, investigators found “multiple concerning incidents where the teacher had physical contact with students which we deemed to be inappropriate.”
Currently, Desmond said Tennessee’s criminal laws on sexual battery require contact with the “intimate parts” of a victim. However, none of the videos or accusations showed that Dalton had touched any of the students in that way, meaning that while his actions were concerning and inappropriate, it did not qualify as sexual battery or any other sexual offense under state law.
The DA said his office was then faced with the question of closing the case and investigation because the conduct did not amount to sexual battery, but he said closing it was “unacceptable.”
After researching the law, Desmond said the only criminal offense that fit the facts and evidence was assault through the “offensive touching” of another, which is a Class B misdemeanor and carries a maximum punishment of six months.
Desmond said he found it to be worth it to prosecute the charges despite the sentence being minimal because “the alternative was to do nothing.” He said if more serious charges had been supported with evidence that they would have been pursued, but that was not the case.
Desmond added that he doesn’t disagree with people’s belief that the sentence is insufficient, saying he would support an effort to amend the law to address scenarios like this.
He said the law as it currently exists is “clearly insufficient,” but he made the decision that some action had to be taken and said he stands by that decision. Dalton was sentenced to the maximum punishment of six months of supervised probation.
Desmond is not the only official to speak out about the case. Blount County Mayor Ed Mitchell called out the school district’s administration and said the current laws need to be changed.
Previous Coverage: ‘I am disgusted’ | Blount County mayor calls out school administration in Joseph Dalton assault case, calls for laws to change
State records obtained by WVLT News show Dalton still has a valid teaching license even after being sentenced on the charges.
Below is Desmond’s full statement on the case:
Copyright 2025 WVLT. All rights reserved.
